Two olive oils sit at the top of the high polyphenol shelf. Both print a big polyphenol number on the product page. The numbers point one way. The cost per tablespoon points the other way.
This article compares the two product pages and the two prices. It is label and pricing research, not a hands on review. I have not tested either oil, and nothing here is sponsored.
The short version: Kosterina Original publishes the higher concentration, at 500+ mg/kg of polyphenols, against 425 mg/kg of total biophenols for the current Blueprint harvest. Kosterina also has the lower sticker price, at $32 for 500 ml against $39 for 750 ml. Blueprint wins on cost per tablespoon, at $0.78 against $0.96. On cost per milligram of polyphenols the two are near tied, at about $0.13 for Blueprint and about $0.14 for Kosterina. Prices are as of November 2026. If you are new to Blueprint, you can get $50 off your first Blueprint order through this referral link, which is more than the price of the bottle.
The Biggest Trap: The Claim Runs on Hydroxytyrosol, Not Total Polyphenols

Most buyers compare the two headline numbers and stop there. That is the trap. The regulated health claim for olive oil does not run on total polyphenols. A 2025 systematic review in Nutrients, indexed on PubMed, sets out the rule from the European Food Safety Authority. The claim requires at least 5 mg of hydroxytyrosol and its derivatives per 20 g of olive oil. Total polyphenols only define the broader high phenolic category, which starts at 250 mg/kg.
Neither product page lets a reader check that claim math. Blueprint posts a total biophenol figure. Its posted lab work has shown free hydroxytyrosol at just 2 mg per kg, and it does not total the derivatives. Kosterina publishes no hydroxytyrosol figure at all on its product page.
So both oils clear the high phenolic bar on totals. Neither page proves the specific claim that the regulation actually covers.
The Two Oils, Side by Side
Figures come from each brand’s own product page. Prices are one time prices, as of November 2026.
| Blueprint Extra Virgin Olive Oil | Kosterina Original Extra Virgin Olive Oil | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $39 | $32 |
| Bottle size | 750 ml | 500 ml |
| Servings per bottle, at 1 tablespoon | 50 | About 33 |
| Polyphenol figure | 425 mg/kg total biophenols, current harvest | 500+ mg/kg |
| Headline claim | 400 mg/kg polyphenols | 500+ mg/kg polyphenols |
| Test method stated | HPLC | Not stated on the product page |
| Cultivar | Not named as a single cultivar | 100 percent Koroneiki |
| Origin on the page | Spain and Peru harvest copy, with a Portuguese lab block | Southern Greece, Peloponnese |
| Current harvest | Alternating hemisphere harvests | November 2025 |
| Cost per tablespoon | $0.78 | $0.96 |
| Cost per 100 ml | $5.20 | $6.40 |
| Polyphenols per tablespoon | About 5.8 mg | About 6.8 mg, at the floor figure |
| Cost per mg of polyphenols | About $0.13 | About $0.14 |
One sourcing note deserves a plain statement. The Blueprint page carries harvest copy for Spain and Peru. Its current harvest lab block labels the tested oil as Portuguese. Those two accounts do not match. Kosterina has no such gap. One cultivar, one region, and one harvest month sit on the one page.
The Cost Math That Matters
A tablespoon is 15 ml. It weighs about 13.7 g.
Blueprint gives 50 tablespoons per bottle. At $39, that is $0.78 per tablespoon. At 425 mg/kg, one tablespoon carries about 5.8 mg of polyphenols. Divide $0.78 by 5.8 mg and the cost is about $0.13 per milligram.
Kosterina gives about 33 tablespoons per bottle. At $32, that is $0.96 per tablespoon. At the floor figure of 500 mg/kg, one tablespoon carries about 6.8 mg of polyphenols. Divide $0.96 by 6.8 mg and the cost is about $0.14 per milligram.
Subscription prices move both numbers a little, without changing the order. Blueprint autoship is $37.05, or about $0.74 per tablespoon. Kosterina Subscribe and Save is $28.80, or about $0.86 per tablespoon. At two tablespoons a day, the costs are $1.56 and $1.92.
A first Blueprint order changes the math once. You can claim $50 off your first Blueprint order with a referral link. The credit is larger than the $39 bottle, and no code is needed.
Where Kosterina Wins
Kosterina wins on concentration. Its floor figure of 500+ mg/kg sits at least 75 mg/kg above the current Blueprint harvest figure of 425 mg/kg.
Kosterina wins on sticker price. A bottle costs $32 against $39. A buyer who compares shelf prices without checking bottle size will see Kosterina as the cheaper oil.
Kosterina wins on the harvest story. The oil is 100 percent Koroneiki, an early harvest, cold pressed in southern Greece within hours of picking. It is a single cultivar oil, never blended, and the current harvest is dated November 2025. The brand also says each harvest is verified by independent third party testing, measured at harvest, with results published for every harvest.
Where Blueprint Wins
Blueprint wins on cost per tablespoon. At $0.78 against $0.96, a daily tablespoon habit costs about 19 percent less with Blueprint.
Blueprint wins on bottle size. A 750 ml bottle holds 50 tablespoons. A 500 ml bottle holds about 33. The Blueprint bottle lasts about half again as long.
Blueprint also states its test method next to its number. The 425 mg/kg figure is labelled HPLC on the page. Kosterina does not name a method or a lab on its product page. Totals from different methods are not directly interchangeable, so a stated method is worth something on its own.
What Each Page Does Not Show
Both numbers describe oil at harvest. Neither was measured in the bottle months later. Polyphenol levels fall over time, so an at harvest figure is a starting point, not a promise about the last pour.
Blueprint prints more lab detail for its current harvest, including 80 percent oleic acid, 0.21 percent free fatty acids, and a peroxide value of 3.7 meq/kg. Kosterina gives context of its own, noting that most supermarket oils contain 50 to 150 mg/kg of polyphenols, and that Original is best used cold and not for high heat cooking.
What to Look For on Any High Polyphenol Olive Oil Label
- A polyphenol figure in mg/kg, not a vague claim about richness or strength.
- Whether the figure is a floor, a headline claim, or a measured harvest result.
- The test method printed next to the number, such as HPLC.
- A hydroxytyrosol figure, and a total for its derivatives, if a health claim is being made.
- Bottle size in ml, so cost per tablespoon can be worked out.
- A harvest date or harvest month, not just a best before date.
- One named cultivar and one named region, if a single origin story matters to you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which oil has more polyphenols?
Kosterina, on the published figures. Original is listed at 500+ mg/kg. The current Blueprint harvest is listed at 425 mg/kg of total biophenols, under a headline claim of 400 mg/kg.
Which oil is cheaper?
It depends on the measure. Kosterina has the lower sticker price, at $32 a bottle against $39. Blueprint has the lower cost per tablespoon, at $0.78 against $0.96, because its bottle holds 750 ml against 500 ml. Prices are as of November 2026.
What does each oil cost per milligram of polyphenols?
About $0.13 per milligram for Blueprint and about $0.14 per milligram for Kosterina. The math uses one tablespoon at a time and the published figures, 425 mg/kg for Blueprint and the 500 mg/kg floor for Kosterina. The two are near tied on this measure.
Does either oil qualify for the European health claim?
A reader cannot verify that from either page. The claim requires at least 5 mg of hydroxytyrosol and its derivatives per 20 g of oil. Blueprint does not total the derivatives, and Kosterina publishes no hydroxytyrosol figure at all.
Why did the Blueprint polyphenol number change?
Harvests change. An earlier harvest was reported at 438 mg/kg in lab work covered on this site. The current figure on the Blueprint page is 425 mg/kg by HPLC, and this article uses that figure.
Which oil should a daily user pick?
Pick on the measure that drives the habit. A daily user who cares most about cost per day lands on Blueprint. A buyer who cares most about concentration, a single cultivar, and a dated harvest lands on Kosterina.
The Bottom Line
This comparison splits cleanly. Kosterina wins on concentration, sticker price, and the single cultivar harvest story. Blueprint wins on cost per tablespoon and bottle size. On cost per milligram of polyphenols, about $0.13 against about $0.14, the two are near tied.
The shared gap matters more than the split. Neither page gives a reader the numbers to verify the regulated claim.
If the Blueprint oil is the one that fits, you can get $50 off your first Blueprint order here and put the credit toward the bottle.
Related reading: