Collagen labels reward a close read. One tub leads with a long list of types. The other leads with a plain dose and almost nothing else.
This article compares the two labels and the two prices. It is label and pricing research, not a hands on review. I have not tested either product, and nothing here is sponsored.
The short version: Blueprint gives 20 g of collagen per scoop, types I, II and III, for $45 and 30 servings, at $1.50 per serving and 7.5 cents per gram. Ancient Nutrition gives 10 g per scoop, 10 types from 4 sources, plus vitamin C and a probiotic, for $49.95 and 45 servings, as of November 2026, at $1.11 per serving and 11.1 cents per gram. Ancient Nutrition is cheaper per serving. Blueprint is cheaper per gram, with double the collagen in one scoop. If you are new to Blueprint, you can get $50 off your first Blueprint order through this referral link, which is more than the price of one pouch.
The Biggest Trap: Counting Types Instead of Grams

The trap is the type count. Ten types sounds like more collagen than three types. On these labels, it is half as much.
Ancient Nutrition lists 10 types in one scoop. That scoop holds 10 g of collagen in total. Blueprint lists 3 types in one scoop. That scoop holds 20 g in total. Type count tells you how many forms are present. It does not tell you how much collagen you get.
Ancient Nutrition also prints one combined weight for its blend. The label gives 10 g for all 4 sources together, with no amount for each type. A type can be present in a very small amount and still appear on the list. Blueprint prints its split more plainly, with a separate type II dose stated in milligrams.
Trial evidence does not rescue the count. A systematic review and meta analysis of oral collagen in Nutrients, listed on PubMed pooled 26 trials with 1,721 people. For elasticity, it found no significant difference by collagen source. More sources did not mean better results.
Read grams first. Read the type list last.
The Two Labels, Side by Side
Amounts are per serving, as printed on the current labels. Prices are one time list prices, as of November 2026.
| Per serving | Blueprint Collagen Peptides | Ancient Nutrition Multi Collagen Protein |
|---|---|---|
| Serving size | 1 scoop, 22.3 g | 1 scoop, 10.1 g |
| Servings per container | 30 | 45 |
| Collagen | 20 g | 10 g |
| Collagen types | I, II and III | I, II, III, IV, V, VII, VIII, X, XII and XXIII |
| Collagen sources | Bovine hide and chicken cartilage | Bovine hide, fermented eggshell membrane, chicken bone broth and fish |
| Protein | 20 g | 9 g |
| Calories | 80 | 35 |
| Vitamin C | None | 90 mg, 100 percent of daily value |
| Probiotic | None | 2 billion CFU Bacillus coagulans |
| Other ingredients | None | See blend note below |
| Price, one time | $45 | $49.95 |
| Cost per serving | $1.50 | $1.11 |
| Cost per gram of collagen | 7.5 cents | 11.1 cents |
The Ancient Nutrition blend weight includes the probiotic inside its 10 g complex. Blueprint has no such mix. Its Other Ingredients line reads None, and the full panel is in my Blueprint Collagen Peptides ingredients breakdown.
Allergens also differ. Ancient Nutrition adds fish and egg through fish collagen and eggshell membrane. Blueprint uses bovine and chicken only.
The Cost Math That Matters
Per serving, Ancient Nutrition wins. It costs $1.11 per scoop against $1.50 for Blueprint, and a tub holds 45 servings against 30.
Per gram of collagen, Blueprint wins, at 7.5 cents against 11.1 cents. Blueprint is about one third cheaper on the ingredient both products are sold for.
The matched dose shows why both figures matter. To get 20 g of collagen from Ancient Nutrition, you need 2 scoops, at $2.22 per day. Two scoops also give 18 g of protein, 180 mg of vitamin C, and 4 billion CFU of probiotic. Blueprint gives the same 20 g for $1.50 per day. At two scoops a day, a 45 serving tub lasts 22.5 days, not 45 days.
If you are a first time Blueprint buyer, you can claim $50 off your first Blueprint order with a referral link, and since one pouch costs $45, the credit covers it. No code needed.
Where Ancient Nutrition Wins
Ancient Nutrition wins on price per serving. At $1.11, a daily scoop costs less, and the tub carries more servings.
It wins on source breadth. Four sources and 10 types give a wider spread than bovine hide and chicken cartilage alone.
It wins on added extras. Each scoop gives 90 mg of vitamin C, a full daily value, and vitamin C has a real role in normal collagen formation in the body. Each scoop also gives 2 billion CFU of Bacillus coagulans, a probiotic Blueprint does not offer at all.
Where Blueprint Wins
Blueprint wins on dose per scoop. One scoop gives 20 g of collagen, double the Ancient Nutrition scoop, with no second scoop needed.
It wins on cost per gram. At 7.5 cents against 11.1 cents, the collagen itself costs less. Per gram of protein the gap is similar, 7.5 cents against about 12.3 cents.
It wins on plainness. The Other Ingredients line is empty, and no blend weight hides how much of each source you get. The label is collagen peptides plus a small stated dose of type II, and nothing else. Blueprint testing claims are covered in Blueprint Third Party Testing.
What the Research Actually Tested
Neither exact product has been trialed against the other. The research covers hydrolyzed collagen as a category.
The Pu 2023 review cited above found that hydrolyzed collagen improved skin hydration and elasticity against placebo. Most trials used far less than 20 g per day. The authors flagged bias and called for larger trials. Results varied by source for hydration, but not significantly by source for elasticity.
The review does not say that 10 types beat 3 types, or that 4 sources beat 2 sources. Dose and consistency are the parts a buyer can control from the label.
Which Buyer Each Label Fits
Pick Ancient Nutrition if one lower cost scoop is your plan and you value the extras, as long as fish and egg fit your diet.
Pick Blueprint if 20 g in one scoop is your plan and you want the lowest cost per gram and a plain label.
What to Look For on Any Collagen Label
- The grams of collagen per serving, printed before you count any types.
- Whether a blend prints one combined weight or a separate dose for each part.
- The sources by name, and any allergens they add, such as fish or egg.
- Cost per serving and cost per gram of collagen, worked out side by side.
- The dose you will actually take each day, and what that dose costs per day.
- Every extra at its printed dose, not just its name on the front of the tub.
- The Other Ingredients line, which should be short for a plain powder.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is 10 types of collagen better than 3 types?
No clear evidence says so. Ancient Nutrition lists 10 types in a 10 g blend with no per type dose printed. Blueprint lists 3 types with 20 g per scoop. The Pu 2023 review found no significant difference in elasticity results by source, so type count alone is not a proven edge.
Which one is cheaper?
Ancient Nutrition is cheaper per serving, at $1.11 against $1.50 for Blueprint, as of November 2026. Blueprint is cheaper per gram, at 7.5 cents against 11.1 cents. At a matched 20 g dose, Blueprint costs $1.50 per day and Ancient Nutrition costs $2.22 per day, because it takes 2 scoops.
How much collagen is in one scoop of Ancient Nutrition?
One scoop gives 10 g of collagen. The scoop weighs 10.1 g and gives 9 g of protein and 35 calories. It also gives 90 mg of vitamin C and 2 billion CFU of Bacillus coagulans. Two scoops give 20 g of collagen.
Does Blueprint Collagen Peptides have vitamin C or a probiotic?
No. Blueprint has neither, and its Other Ingredients line reads None. Ancient Nutrition adds both in each scoop, 90 mg of vitamin C and 2 billion CFU of probiotic.
Is either powder vegan?
No. Both use animal sources. Blueprint uses bovine hide and chicken cartilage. Ancient Nutrition uses bovine hide, eggshell membrane, chicken bone broth, and fish. Collagen is an animal product by definition.
The Bottom Line
This pair splits the win. Ancient Nutrition wins per serving, on source breadth, and on extras. Blueprint wins on dose per scoop, on cost per gram, and on plainness.
Choose by the dose you will take. At 10 g a day with extras, Ancient Nutrition fits. At 20 g a day with a plain label, Blueprint fits for less per gram. If the Blueprint label fits, you can get $50 off your first Blueprint order here and put the credit toward your first pouch.
Related reading: